Tax Valuation Strategies for Distressed and Over-Levered Companies

Valuation Outlook

November 17, 2026

Importance of Defensible Valuations in Times of Distress, Debt and Tax Planning

Private-sector borrowing increased substantially during and immediately following the COVID-19 pandemic, when historically low interest rates gave companies access to inexpensive capital. For some businesses, leverage accumulated during that period continues to create challenges as higher borrowing costs and uneven operating performance put pressure on capital structures.

Following the initial pandemic shock, the Federal Reserve lowered the federal funds target range to 0%–0.25%. U.S. nonfinancial business debt increased from approximately $16.2 trillion at the end of 2019 to approximately $17.7 trillion at the end of 2020, an increase of roughly 9%.

Because much of this financing carried multiyear maturities, some companies continue to contend with leverage established in a substantially different interest-rate environment. As such, businesses with highly leveraged capital structures can be particularly sensitive to deteriorating operating performance, refinancing risk and changes in enterprise value.

In certain circumstances, well-supported company- and legal-entity-level valuations can play an important role in tax planning and restructuring. Two areas in which valuation may be particularly significant are worthless stock deductions and potential exceptions or exclusions from cancellation-of-indebtedness income (CODI).

Current Landscape

For highly leveraged companies, the situations outlined above may create financial challenges but also yield potential tax-planning opportunities. Worthless stock deductions and exclusions from CODI relate to Sections 165 and 108, respectively, of the Internal Revenue Code.

Under certain circumstances, a corporate shareholder may be entitled to a tax deduction when stock in a subsidiary or another corporation becomes wholly worthless. Depending on the facts and the relationship between the entities, the resulting loss may receive capital or ordinary loss treatment.

Separately, a debt restructuring, modification or discharge can give rise to CODI. The Internal Revenue Code provides several exceptions and exclusions that may reduce or eliminate the amount recognized as taxable income under qualifying circumstances. One of the most significant provisions for distressed companies is the insolvency exclusion, which generally permits CODI to be excluded from income to the extent the taxpayer's liabilities exceed the fair market value of its assets immediately before the debt discharge.

Valuation therefore is an important component of both analyses. Independent, well-supported valuation work can help taxpayers substantiate the economic facts underlying a tax position and prepare documentation capable of withstanding scrutiny from tax authorities.

Worthless Stock Considerations

Determining whether stock is worthless involves more than demonstrating poor financial performance or negative book equity. A taxpayer generally must establish that the stock became wholly worthless during the relevant tax year.

Although many of the techniques used in a worthless stock analysis resemble those employed in conventional business and equity valuations, the analysis often requires particular attention to the value of individual legal entities within a broader corporate organization.

This can create challenges for multinationals and other complex organizations whose financial planning processes are conducted primarily at the consolidated, segment or business-unit level. A company may maintain three- to five-year strategic projections for a business unit, for example, without preparing corresponding forecasts for each legal entity within that business unit.

When a legal-entity valuation is required, management may need to develop or allocate financial projections at the entity level and document why those projections appropriately reflect the entity's expected economic performance. The analysis also should support other significant valuation assumptions, which may include discount rates, market multiples, among others.

The objective is not merely to demonstrate that an entity is distressed, but to develop a well-supported conclusion regarding whether any value remains attributable to the relevant equity interest as of the applicable valuation date.

Cancellation-of-Indebtedness Income

Valuation can also play a critical role in evaluating potential exclusions from CODI.

Debt forgiveness or certain debt restructurings may result in taxable CODI. However, the tax rules provide several exceptions and exclusions. For financially distressed taxpayers, one important provision is the insolvency exclusion.

For this purpose, insolvency generally is measured immediately before the debt discharge by comparing the taxpayer's liabilities with the fair market value of its assets. CODI may generally be excluded under the insolvency provision up to the amount by which liabilities exceed the fair market value of those assets.

Consider a simplified example in which a taxpayer has $500 million of liabilities immediately before a debt discharge and assets with an aggregate fair market value of $300 million. The taxpayer may have an insolvency amount of $200 million, and therefore a material reduction in the amount of taxable income recognized (although with a corresponding reduction in basis), subject to the detailed requirements of the applicable tax rules. A well-supported valuation of the taxpayer's assets can therefore be central to substantiating the amount of a claimed insolvency exclusion.

As with a worthless stock analysis, the valuation must be consistent with the relevant legal entities and its underlying assets and liabilities. Robust documentation of methodologies, assumptions and historical and projected financial information is particularly important when a tax position may later be examined by tax authorities.

The Importance of Early Valuation Planning

Both worthless stock and CODI analyses benefit from early planning. Historical financial information, contemporaneous forecasts, board materials, legal agreements and transaction documents can become more difficult to reconstruct after a restructuring has occurred. Beginning the valuation process early can help companies identify information gaps, resolve inconsistencies and create a contemporaneous record supporting the conclusions ultimately reflected on a tax return.

Coordination among a company's tax, finance, legal and valuation professionals is imperative. Valuation conclusions should reflect not only the economics of the business, but also the specific legal entities, debt instruments and transactions relevant to the applicable tax analysis.

Valuation Support

Kroll is an independent global provider of tax valuation and advisory services. Our professionals assist companies and their advisers with legal-entity valuations and other analyses relevant to tax restructurings, worthless stock positions, cancellation-of-indebtedness matters and other tax valuation related matters.

Kroll's valuation professionals also have extensive experience and success supporting taxpayers and their advisers in examinations and other tax controversy matters where the defensibility of valuation assumptions and conclusions can be critical.

Please contact the professionals below to learn more about Kroll's tax valuation capabilities and how we can assist.

Stay Ahead with Kroll

Valuation Services

When companies require an objective and independent assessment of value, they look to Kroll.

Tax Valuation

Kroll specializes in tax valuation-related consulting.