While strong profitability usually supports higher bank valuations, an analysis of 125 publicly traded U.S. banks finds that this relationship is much weaker among banks with $30 billion to $50 billion in assets. In this group, return on average tangible common equity (ROATE) explains relatively little of the difference in price to tangible book value (P/TBV).
Metrics tied to earnings resilience show much stronger relationships with valuation. Banks with more core deposits, fewer nonaccrual loans and less reliance on brokered deposits generally command higher multiples. These factors help investors judge whether current returns can withstand changes in interest rates, funding conditions and credit performance. The findings show association, not causation.
The broader takeaway is that current profitability is only a starting point. Banks should connect their returns to funding quality, credit performance, expected growth, capital needs and strategic choices. Clearly explaining the durability of earnings can help support valuations and expand a bank’s strategic options.
To read the full analysis, download the whitepaper below:
Stay Ahead with Kroll
Valuation Services
When companies require an objective and independent assessment of value, they look to Kroll.



