Thu, Apr 19, 2018
The Price of Everything but the Value of Nothing
Broker quotes and pricing services have long been the Achilles heel of valuation of infrequently traded investments.
Executive Summary
Apr 19, 2018
Too Much of a Good Thing?
Apr 18, 2018
Too Much Too Soon?
Apr 19, 2018
Cyber Risks Beyond Your Four Walls
Apr 19, 2018
Brexit: The Catalyst for Substance Over Style in Asset Management
Apr 19, 2018
A Reality Check
Apr 19, 2018
New Priorities at the SEC
Apr 19, 2018
The Consequences of Concentration in Private Equity
Apr 19, 2018
The SEC Looks to the Most Vulnerable
Apr 27, 2018
Client Protection at the Heart of MiFID II
Apr 19, 2018
The Paradise Papers: The Unreported Facts
Apr 19, 2018
What’s in a Name? It’s a Question Regulators Are Increasingly Asking
Apr 19, 2018
New Guidance From The Trump Administration Regarding FCPA Prosecutions
Apr 19, 2018
Lifting the Veil
Apr 19, 2018
A Fool’s Errand
Apr 19, 2018
Alternative Data Brings Different Problems
Apr 19, 2018
The Price of Everything but the Value of Nothing
Apr 19, 2018
Counting the Cost
Apr 19, 2018
A Big Step Towards Consistency in Fair Value
Apr 19, 2018
Finally Addressing Forgotten Assets
Apr 19, 2018
- View all articles
Read Global Regulatory Outlook 2018
A lack of rigor means banks, hedge funds and even credit funds too often accept quotes that don’t undergo scrutiny.
No longer. The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) has come to the conclusion others reached long ago: The emperor may be wearing no clothes.
In its proposed new guidance for auditors on assessing the relevance of pricing information from brokers and pricing services, the PCAOB says it’s no longer enough to rely on indicative prices or quotes with limitations. Quotes must reflect actual trades, or a willingness to transact without limiting conditions.
In fact, the considerations where valuations use brokers’ quotes or pricing services are three-fold: prices are (i) contemporaneous, (ii) actionable (if a broker) and (iii) congruent—they need to be quotes for trading a similar size, or unit of account, to the holding being valued.
Even where fair values are based on quoted prices or transactions in active markets for the same or similar financial instruments, auditors are required to evaluate the process. Where there are no appropriate recent transactions to support the valuation, the auditor will evaluate the appropriateness of the valuation method and the reasonableness of observable and unobservable inputs used by the pricing service, or, in the case of brokers, whether quotes are timely, binding and without restrictions, limitations or disclaimers.
Effectively, auditors need to see that valuations are based, if not on actual transactions, then on a robust pricing model. Simply taking the broker’s or pricing service’s word for it won’t be sufficient. It will be up to asset holders to provide evidence to the auditor, but brokers, too, are likely to feel increasing pressure from their clients to meet that need.
Furthermore, the impact of the change will also be felt outside the United States, because the guidance will apply to audits of any entities with a Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) registration, wherever they’re based. In addition, it’s likely to prove increasingly uncomfortable for auditors in other jurisdictions to continue to blindly accept broker quotes or pricing service data now that the shakiness of their foundations is being exposed.
Financial Services Compliance and Regulation
End-to-end governance, advisory and monitorship solutions to detect, mitigate, drive efficiencies and remediate operational, legal, compliance and regulatory risk.
Financial Crime Prevention
Financial crime risk has again risen to the top of the regulatory agenda, and remains one of the most immediate risks for many firms, with criminals constantly seeking new ways to circumvent protective controls.
U.S. Compliance Services
Comprehensive support for asset managers registering in the U.S.
European Compliance Services
Comprehensive compliance and regulatory support for EU firms.
French Regulation
A range of support from a review of your suitability arrangements, training, controls and procedures to conducting bespoke reviews on past business activities.
UK Compliance Services
Comprehensive compliance and regulatory support for FCA authorized firms.
Irish Regulation
Kroll is uniquely placed to assist firms in negotiating the regulatory landscape.
Singapore Regulation
Kroll's experienced team provides practical compliance and regulatory advice to financial institutions in Singapore.
Channel Islands Regulation
Kroll provides a range of regulatory and compliance consulting services for firms registered in the Channel Islands.
Regulatory Advice and Consulting Services
Assistance to develop, implement, and manage global compliance and regulatory consulting programs.